Understanding The Montreal Screw Job: A Deep Dive Into Wrestling's Most Controversial Moment

The Montreal Screw Job is one of the most infamous incidents in professional wrestling history, sparking debates and discussions that continue to this day. This event not only changed the landscape of wrestling but also significantly impacted the careers of those involved. In this article, we will explore the intricate details surrounding the Montreal Screw Job, its implications, and its legacy in the wrestling world.

The incident occurred on November 9, 1997, during a match between Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels at the Survivor Series pay-per-view event in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. As the match unfolded, a premeditated plan was executed that led to Bret Hart losing the WWF Championship against his will. This event raised numerous questions about ethics in professional wrestling, the nature of scripted outcomes, and the trust between wrestlers and promoters.

In this comprehensive article, we will delve into the background, the events leading up to the Screw Job, the aftermath, and the ongoing discussions surrounding its impact on professional wrestling. Whether you are a long-time wrestling fan or new to the sport, this exploration of the Montreal Screw Job will provide valuable insights into one of the industry’s most pivotal moments.

Table of Contents

• 1. Background of the Montreal Screw Job
• 2. The Screw Job Explained
• 3. Aftermath and Reactions
• 4. Long-Term Impact on Wrestling
• 5. Bret Hart's Perspective
• 6. Shawn Michaels' Perspective
• 7. Vince McMahon's Role
• 8. The Legacy of the Montreal Screw Job

1. Background of the Montreal Screw Job

The Montreal Screw Job was not just a random occurrence; it was the culmination of a series of events and tensions between wrestlers, promoters, and the wrestling audience. Bret Hart, the reigning WWF Champion, was set to leave for WCW after his contract expired. He had agreed to drop the title to Shawn Michaels, but only under specific circumstances that were not met during the match.

Hart was known for his strong work ethic and dedication to the wrestling business. He had built a legacy and rapport with fans and fellow wrestlers alike. However, as negotiations with WCW progressed, tensions rose between Hart and WWF owner Vince McMahon, leading to a breakdown of trust.

The situation was further complicated by the fact that the match was taking place in Hart's home country of Canada, where he was a national hero. This added an emotional layer to the event, making the Screw Job even more controversial.

2. The Screw Job Explained

During the Survivor Series match, Bret Hart was in control when the referee, Earl Hebner, unexpectedly called for the bell, declaring Shawn Michaels the winner and new WWF Champion. This call was made without Hart's consent, leading to a chaotic scene in the ring as Hart realized he had been double-crossed.

Key Players Involved

• Bret Hart: The victim of the Screw Job, Hart's reaction was one of shock and betrayal.
• Shawn Michaels: The rival who benefitted from the situation, Michaels had a complicated relationship with Hart.
• Vince McMahon: The mastermind behind the Screw Job, McMahon's decision has been widely criticized.

What Led to the Screw Job?

The decision to execute the Screw Job stemmed from Hart's refusal to lose the title in his home country. McMahon, fearing that Hart would take the championship to WCW, felt he had no choice but to take matters into his own hands. This led to a breakdown of communication and trust between the parties involved, culminating in the infamous decision to proceed with the Screw Job.

3. Aftermath and Reactions

The immediate aftermath of the Montreal Screw Job was filled with chaos and controversy. Bret Hart, furious about the betrayal, famously punched Vince McMahon in the face in the locker room after the event. Hart's departure from WWF and subsequent arrival in WCW were highly publicized and marked a significant shift in the wrestling landscape.

Fans and fellow wrestlers were divided in their opinions on the Screw Job. Some viewed it as a necessary evil for the promotion, while others saw it as a betrayal of trust. The incident also sparked a wave of discussions about ethics and honesty in professional wrestling, leading to a reevaluation of how scripted matches should be handled.

4. Long-Term Impact on Wrestling

The long-term impact of the Montreal Screw Job extends beyond the individuals directly involved. It changed the way wrestling promotions conducted business and how wrestlers negotiated their contracts. The incident highlighted the importance of trust and communication in an industry that thrives on storytelling and collaboration.

Furthermore, the Screw Job contributed to the rising popularity of the Attitude Era in WWF, as the promotion sought to capitalize on the controversy and the real-life tensions between wrestlers. This era brought about a shift in storytelling and character development, resulting in increased viewership and a new wave of fans.

5. Bret Hart's Perspective

For Bret Hart, the Montreal Screw Job was a personal and professional betrayal. He has spoken extensively about the incident in interviews and documentaries, expressing his feelings of anger and humiliation. Hart felt that the way the situation was handled was disrespectful to him as a performer and a champion.

Despite the betrayal, Hart has since reconciled with the wrestling industry and has made appearances in various promotions. His perspective on the Screw Job has evolved, but he remains critical of the way it was executed.

6. Shawn Michaels' Perspective

Shawn Michaels, on the other hand, had a different view of the Screw Job. While he acknowledged the controversy, Michaels has often maintained that the decision was necessary for the company's future. He has discussed the incident in various interviews, reflecting on the pressures and challenges faced by wrestlers in the business.

Over the years, Michaels and Hart have reconciled, and their relationship has improved significantly. This reconciliation has allowed both men to move forward in their careers and personal lives.

7. Vince McMahon's Role

Vince McMahon's role in the Montreal Screw Job cannot be understated. As the owner of WWF, he made the controversial decision to execute the plan that led to Hart's betrayal. McMahon has faced criticism for his actions, but he has also defended his choices, claiming that he was acting in the best interest of the company.

McMahon's decision ultimately reshaped the wrestling industry and set a precedent for how promotions handle similar situations in the future. His willingness to take risks and push boundaries has been both praised and condemned, making him a polarizing figure in wrestling history.

8. The Legacy of the Montreal Screw Job

The legacy of the Montreal Screw Job continues to resonate within the wrestling community. It serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of trust and communication in an industry built on collaboration. The incident has also inspired countless discussions and debates about the ethics of professional wrestling and the responsibilities of promoters and performers.

Additionally, the Montreal Screw Job has been referenced in various wrestling storylines, documentaries, and interviews, ensuring that it remains a significant part of wrestling lore. It has become a defining moment in the careers of Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, and Vince McMahon, influencing how fans perceive these individuals and the industry as a whole.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Montreal Screw Job was a watershed moment in professional wrestling that changed the landscape of the industry forever. The betrayal felt by Bret Hart and the controversial actions of Vince McMahon continue to spark debates and discussions among fans and historians alike. As we reflect on this pivotal event, it is essential to acknowledge its impact on trust, ethics, and the future of wrestling.

If you found this article informative, we encourage you to leave your comments below, share it with fellow wrestling fans, and explore more articles on our site about wrestling history and its fascinating stories.

Penutup

Thank you for taking the time to read our in-depth analysis of the Montreal Screw Job. We hope you found it engaging and enlightening. We invite you to return to our site for more content and discussions about the ever-evolving world of professional wrestling.